World Association of Newspapers and News Publishers

New York Times likely on firm grounds in Trump tax returns case thanks to First Amendment

World News Publishing Focus

World News Publishing Focus
Your Guide to the Changing Media Landscape

New York Times likely on firm grounds in Trump tax returns case thanks to First Amendment

The Washington Post reports that US Federal Law punishes the unauthorized publication of tax information. In addition, New York law deems unlawful the disclosure of “the amount of income or any particulars set forth (...) in any report”, and the legislation of New Jersey punishes with up to 18 months of prison time “any person ... divulging, disclosing or using [tax] information”.

If sued, the immediate best defence to resort to for the Times would be one based on First Amendment. As the Post notes, claiming the superior “public interest” of the news would not necessarily be enough. In the words of Jonathan Zittrain from Harvard Law School "the courts could say, if the public thinks the tax returns are so important, let it demand that the candidate authorize the IRS to release them on pain of losing votes."

Concurring Opinion posed to 11 experts the question of how likely would a First Amendment defence hold in a prosecution against the New York Times. The general conclusion is that the publication of the documents would probably remain unpunished, unless the paper participated in their unlawful acquisition.


Elena Perotti's picture

Elena Perotti


2016-10-04 13:53

Author information

The World Editors Forum is the organisation within the World Association of Newspapers devoted to newspaper editors worldwide. The Editors Weblog (, launched in January 2004, is a WEF initiative designed to facilitate the diffusion of information relevant to newspapers and their editors.

The news publishing industry is experiencing transformation at an ever-growing pace, with new policy issues arising as the landscape changes.

We will be examining policy discussions that will define the news publishing environment of the future, the key topics being internet governance, privacy and copyright. Click here to learn more about our work.

WAN-IFRA Media Policy team and experts.

© 2020 WAN-IFRA - World Association of News Publishers

Footer Navigation